Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Fired nurse wins arbitration; JFL fights effort for settlement amount, still owes arbitrator

The Governor Juan F. Luis Hospital and Medical Center on St. Croix. The hospital is facing a court case brought by the Virgin Islands State Nurses Association over the 2022 firing of an emergency room nurse, which an arbitrator later ruled was without just cause.
WTJX/Tom Eader
The Governor Juan F. Luis Hospital and Medical Center on St. Croix. The hospital is facing a court case brought by the Virgin Islands State Nurses Association over the 2022 firing of an emergency room nurse, which an arbitrator later ruled was without just cause.

ST. CROIX — The union representing registered nurses at Governor Juan F. Luis Hospital and Medical Center asked a Superior Court judge Monday to enter default against the Virgin Islands government and two of its agencies, nearly two years after an arbitrator ruled the hospital fired an emergency room nurse without just cause and with the nurse still unpaid.
           
The Virgin Islands State Nurses Association Collective Bargaining Unit filed the motion on behalf of nurse Michele Montoya in its case to confirm and enforce the arbitrator’s December 20, 2024, decision. The union says Montoya was owed $275,076.40 as of February 2025, an amount it says has kept growing. The motion asks Judge Venetia Harvey Velázquez to find the VI government, the Department of Health, and the Office of Collective Bargaining in default for failing to answer the petition.
           
The hospital’s parent corporation, the Virgin Islands Government Hospitals and Health Facilities Corporation, asked the court in October to dismiss the case, arguing there is no final arbitration award to enforce because a compensation figure was never set.
           
Velázquez has not ruled on either motion, and no hearing has been scheduled, according to the court docket.

Fired after speaking to a news outlet:
Montoya was working a shift in JFL’s emergency room on the evening of May 16, 2022, while staff treated two gunshot victims, one of whom died, according to the arbitrator’s decision. During that time, a man came in through the open ambulance bay doors “yelling that people were trying to kill him” and walked past an empty security guard post into the hospital, the decision states. A second person later came in the same way.
           
Montoya filed an incident report with hospital administration and later spoke by phone with a reporter for The Virgin Islands Consortium, which published a story on May 20, 2022, that was critical of security at JFL.
           
Three days later, then-CEO Douglas Koch sent Montoya a termination letter. The letter accused her of falsification or misrepresentation of material information, breaching confidentiality rules, and violating the federal health privacy law known as HIPAA by telling the media that one victim was dead on arrival.
           
“After an investigation of the information you revealed to the media and the observance of video footage of the night in question, management has ascertained that adequate security was available and engaged in carrying out their duties as patients and victims arrived,” the letter states.
           
The hospital upheld the firing after a grievance hearing in June 2022, and the union demanded arbitration that July.

The arbitrator’s decision:
Arbitrator H. A. Curt Otto, a St. Croix attorney, held a hearing on October 30, 2024, after JFL and Montoya agreed in writing in August 2024 to take the dispute to final and binding arbitration outside of the Public Employees Relations Board’s involvement.
           
In his 11-page decision, Otto found the firing was without just cause and granted Montoya’s appeal.
           
“There was no misleading or misrepresentation in the information provided by Ms. Montoya to the Consortium reporter,” Otto wrote. “The video made clear that there was no security guard at the security post, and that fact enabled two persons to wander in, with one yelling he was going to be shot.”
           
Otto found that the HIPAA accusation in Koch’s letter was false, because the information that one victim died and one survived had been released by the Virgin Islands Police Department, not Montoya.
           
“As much as the JFL administration might want to sweep such concerns under the table, or to characterize them as misleading, the incident itself was deeply concerning and undeniable,” he wrote.
           
The decision states that no one was able to testify who gave Montoya’s confidential incident report to the news outlet. Montoya testified she did not, and Otto wrote that an unidentified third party may have leaked it. He also noted that Darice Plaskett, a former interim CEO whom JFL qualified as an expert witness, was not willing to testify she would have fired Montoya, saying it would depend on other factors.
           
Otto did not set a dollar amount. The parties told him they could agree on compensation if he ruled for Montoya, and he deferred to them while offering to decide the amount himself if they could not, according to the decision. He ordered the two sides to split the arbitration costs evenly.

More than $275,000 demanded:
On February 10, 2025, attorney Mally Rutherford, of McChain Hamm & Associates, sent JFL a demand totaling $275,076.40. That figure includes $216,381.45 in back pay, which is $359,213 in lost pay minus the $142,831.55 Montoya earned elsewhere after she was fired. It also includes $34,650 in rent she paid after leaving the island, $17,544.95 in travel costs, and $6,500 for moving back to St. Croix. The letter also sought reinstatement and a public apology and offered a payment plan.
           
The hospital also never paid the arbitrator. In a July 14, 2026, letter to Rutherford, Otto confirmed JFL owed him $2,718.75, its half of his $5,437.50 bill.
           
“As a result, any further proceedings involving JFL are not possible,” Otto wrote.

The court case:
The union filed its petition in Superior Court on St. Croix on August 7, asking the court to confirm the award, order the respondents to pay back pay and benefits, and have the court itself calculate the amount owed, with interest, because the arbitrator can no longer do it.
           
On October 12, attorney Julie Beberman, VIGHHFC’s legal counsel, moved to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction. She argued that under territorial law an arbitration award must be a “final decision binding on both parties” before a court can enforce it, and that Otto’s decision is not final because compensation was never decided.
           
“The court also does not have jurisdiction to calculate such damages in the first instance,” the motion states.
           
Beberman wrote that the union never tried to take Otto up on his offer to decide compensation, and that if the hospital had refused to arbitrate, the union’s remedy would have been an order from PERB, not a lawsuit.
           
The union responded on November 2 that the decision is final on the question that was arbitrated, Montoya’s firing, and that only the amount is left. It also argued that the hospital caused the very problem it now relies on.
           
“Respondent cannot create the alleged jurisdictional defect through its own nonpayment and then rely upon that defect to avoid judicial enforcement of the arbitrator’s decision and order,” the opposition states.

Government missed extended deadline, union says:
Monday’s motion targets the three government respondents, not the hospital corporation. According to the motion, Governor Albert Bryan Jr. was served on August 18 and the Office of the Attorney General on August 21, making an answer due by September 20.
           
On or about October 20, the Attorney General’s Office called the union’s lawyers, said it had realized the government had been served, and asked for an extension until November 9, the motion states. The union agreed, but the government had still not filed a response as of Monday, according to the motion. A proposed entry of default was filed with it.
           
Earlier in the case, Velázquez ordered the parties to meet and confer on a discovery plan, then vacated that order two days later, on September 4, because the defendants had not yet answered the complaint.

Hospital’s other debts:
The case comes as VIGHHFC fights separate efforts to collect on a $6.36 million federal judgment won by creditors who say they own JFL’s operating equipment.

READ MORE: Creditors say they own JFL’s operating equipment and can seize hospital corporation assets

In that case, VIGHHFC has argued in a November 5 motion, also filed by Beberman, that it is part of the Virgin Islands government and that any payment on that judgment would have to come from taxpayer money.

Tom Eader is an award-winning journalist and chief reporter for WTJX with more than two decades of experience covering the Virgin Islands. A native of South Bend, Indiana, he earned a bachelor’s degree in journalism from Ball State University and moved to St. Croix in 2003 to join The St. Croix Avis, where he worked for 20 years as a reporter and photographer and served as Bureau Chief from 2013 until the paper’s closure at the beginning of 2024. He joined WTJX in January 2024, where he continues to deliver thorough, thoughtful reporting on issues important to the Virgin Islands Community. Email: teader@wtjx.org | Phone: 340-227-4463