Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Surge in illegal entry cases leads to special designation of magistrate judges in VI District Court

The District Court of the Virgin Islands Ron de Lugo Federal Building on St. Thomas.
WTJX/Roshan Sookram
The District Court of the Virgin Islands Ron de Lugo Federal Building on St. Thomas. 

ST. THOMAS – In response to a surge in immigration-related cases, the District Court of the Virgin Islands has expanded the authority of magistrate judges, giving them full responsibility over improper entry cases.

Effective April 7, all complaints brought under 8 U.S.C. § 1325(a), which pertains to “improper entry by an alien,” will be assigned to magistrate judges on a rotating basis. This section of the United States Code outlines the criminal penalties for individuals who enter, or attempt to enter, the United States unlawfully.

In an order signed on Monday, Chief Judge Robert Molloy cited an “inordinate number” of these cases being filed in the Division of St. Thomas/St. John and stated that this shift is intended to “maintain the proper administration of justice and to appropriately allocate court resources.”

Magistrate judges typically handle the early and more routine parts of cases, like initial hearings and bail decisions, therefore easing the caseload of district judges and allowing them to focus resources on more complex legal proceedings.

However, under this new arrangement, magistrate judges in the Virgin Islands will take on full responsibility for these specific immigration cases.

According to the order, magistrate judges assigned to these cases will be “specially designated” with authority under 18 U.S.C. § 3401(a) to conduct trials, issue convictions, and sentence individuals accused of committing such misdemeanors within the judicial district. The order also allows these magistrate judges to request presentence investigations through the court’s probation services before issuing a sentence.

While the move highlights the growing strain on judicial resources in the territory, the assignment of U.S. district judges will remain unchanged for any of these cases brought before April 7.

Isabelle Teare is a new member of the WTJX team. She is a recent graduate of Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism, where she specialized in radio broadcast and audio storytelling. Raised on the island of St. Thomas since the age of seven, Isabelle attended and graduated from Antilles School before moving to Washington, D.C. where she earned her bachelor’s degree from Georgetown University in Justice and Peace Studies. Originally planning on pursuing a career in the law, Isabelle worked as a paralegal on St. Thomas for several years before making the decision to pursue her passion for storytelling.
Latest Episodes
   
Download on the Apple App Store Get it on Google Play